By Elizabeth Johnson
People in Wake Forest work hard. When they come together downtown for community events to celebrate holidays, explore local businesses, and see old friends, White Street really fills up with people! I salute all the merchants who make the community so special, every day. Our town is truly friendly, very beautiful, and exceptionally good.
Because I know how hard our local business owners work, I worry about the wealth taxes now being promoted in Washington. Sen. Bernie Sanders and Rep. Ro Khanna have proposed a 5 percent tax every year on billionaires’ net worth. Sen. Elizabeth Warren’s plan starts at $50 million. Other proposals would tax unrealized gains, the rise in what you own, before you ever sell it. Every one of them is sold as a tax on someone else.
New York City just showed us how that ends. This year, its mayor told Albany to raise taxes on the wealthy or he would raise property taxes 9.5 percent instead, on more than 3 million homes and more than 100,000 commercial buildings. Commercial buildings are where shops pay rent. The plan was eventually shelved, but the message was plain. When taxing the rich doesn’t produce the money, the bill moves to Main Street.
And it rarely produces the money. The very wealthy are the people best able to move their assets, restructure, or leave. Small business owners can’t. Most of what most small business owners are worth is tied up in the business itself: the inventory on the shelves, the fixtures, the building if they own it, and the value of a name that took years to build. None of that is cash. A tax on what we own would come due whether or not they had a good holiday season, and the only way to pay it would be to sell something we need, or sell out entirely.
Then there is where the money goes. A wealth tax doesn’t go back into anyone’s paycheck or retirement savings. It goes to more spending in Washington, and in my experience, programs funded by optimistic revenue projections rarely shrink when the revenue doesn’t show up. Somebody else just gets asked to pay.
Many of the people who shop downtown are retirees, living on savings built over a working lifetime. A tax on gains that exist only on paper, charged year after year, would eat into those savings once the threshold starts to slide.
Even California said no. This month, voters in one of the most progressive states in the country rejected Proposition 40, a tax on billionaires’ wealth, by double digits. The opposition wasn’t just business groups. It included teachers, firefighters, building trades unions, Planned Parenthood, and Gov. Gavin Newsom, who warned that the money would never materialize and the wealthy would simply leave. If California won’t do it, Washington shouldn’t either.
Washington already taxes what we earn. It should not tax what we own. Sen. Ted Budd, Senator-elect Roy Cooper, and our House delegation should say clearly that they will oppose any federal tax on net worth or unrealized gains, at any threshold. Downtowns like ours survive because families can keep their businesses going and pass them on. Washington shouldn’t make that harder.
Elizabeth Johnson is a past Board Chair of the Wake Forest Chamber of Commerce and a merchant in downtown Wake Forest.

