Subscribe to our FREE daily newsletter.

Opinion, Politics

Gerard Scimeca: Three Hospital Reforms North Carolina Should Prioritize

By Gerard Scimeca, Chairman, Consumer Action for a Strong Economy (CASE)

For voters across the U.S., the midterm elections were a referendum on the cost of living. But while much of the conversation centered on groceries and gas prices, one study found that six out of every ten voters reported being very concerned about the rising cost of healthcare.

With narrower margins and divided government, North Carolina now has an opportunity to pursue bipartisan cooperation on common sense solutions, primarily affordable healthcare. Such policy can be complex and divisive; but patients shouldn’t have to navigate an increasingly expensive and broken system while lawmakers debate how to fix it. Three practical reforms offer a place to start.

First, North Carolina should make hospital price transparency a reality, not just a federal requirement. Patients often need treatment they cannot safely delay or decline, giving hospitals considerable leverage. Keeping prices low depends on patients’ ability to compare options and prices.

Federal hospital transparency rules requiring public disclosure of standard charges and information about services patients can schedule in advance have been in effect since 2021. North Carolina should strengthen its existing reporting framework by adopting those federal standards into state law and giving state officials explicit authority to investigate and penalize violations. Transparency alone won’t solve rising healthcare costs, but it is a necessary foundation for competition and accountability.

Second, lawmakers should more closely scrutinize hospital consolidation and its consequences for consumers. Hospital mergers can raise prices without producing corresponding improvements in care. Take the proposed Atrium-WakeMed which could reshape care across the region, including for the more than 1.25 million people who live in Wake County. Atrium already charges the State Health Plan 15 to 40 percent more than WakeMed does for the same services. Combining these systems raises legitimate questions about whether patients would face higher prices and fewer choices.

Given how deeply these deals affect patients in this state, lawmakers should ensure that the attorney general has the tools to evaluate them. Gov. Josh Stein recently called for greater authority to review hospital transactions, the legislators should examine how stronger oversight could protect competition.

They could start by requiring advance notice of major transactions and strengthening state officials’ authority to challenge deals that threaten competition. Reviews should consider the likely effects on prices and access, not simply the benefits hospital executives promise. Those promises should be enforceable and publicly tracked.

Third, North Carolina should demand greater accountability from nonprofit hospitals receiving valuable tax exemptions. A legislative analysis  presented this February put the local revenue forgone through nonprofit hospital property-tax exemptions at about $130 million annually. That’s $130 million in forgone public revenue, with no minimum charity-care spending standard attached to the exemption.

One analysis of North Carolina’s nonprofit hospitals found that 37% of those studied received more in estimated tax benefits than they spent on financial assistance and other community investments. When hospitals receive public subsidies, taxpayers deserve a clear accounting of what their communities receive in return.

Lawmakers don’t have to start from scratch. Sen. Jim Burgin and Sen. Julie Mayfield have already proposed tying hospital tax benefits to charity care in Senate Bill 895. The proposal would have linked sales-tax refunds and property-tax exemptions to qualifying charity care spending. It offers a concrete framework for discussing how hospitals can be held accountable for the benefits they receive.

Healthcare should work for patients, not just the institutions delivering it. The new legislature has an opportunity to turn the affordability campaign promises into measurable progress for North Carolina families. Healthcare costs won’t come down through the promises alone. Patients need transparency, meaningful choices, and accountability from the hospitals they depend on. 

Get NC political news in your inbox

Free weekday newsletter. Unsubscribe anytime.

Newsletter signup

Complete any confirmation steps below.

Have a message for North Carolina?

Reach readers who follow state policy, elections and the issues shaping their communities.

Advertise with Us