Subscribe to our FREE daily newsletter.

Opinion, Politics, State Government

OP-ED | Bobby Hurst: US Senate Should Stop Durbin-Marshall Credit Card Mandate

Bobby Hurst

Fayetteville has a lot to be proud of. New small businesses are opening across our city, from food trucks and restaurants to downtown storefronts. Each one represents someone who took a chance on building something in this community. I know what that takes because I’ve done it myself, and I spent a decade on the city council working to make Fayetteville a place where people could start a business and succeed.

Protecting our economic growth is important to me, which is why I’m writing to urge Senator Tillis and Senator Budd to reject a proposal that would make it harder for small businesses to get off the ground and compete: the Durbin-Marshall credit card mandates.

The Durbin-Marshall credit card mandates would require banks to put at least two payment networks on every credit card they issue, one of which must be an alternative to the popular networks people use today. While the stated goal is to lower transaction processing fees, I worry that this promise won’t materialize and local entrepreneurs would lose access to credit.

Although the law technically exempts smaller banks and credit unions from the mandates, such sweeping changes won’t stay contained. Local lenders rely on processing fees to fund small business loans and business credit cards. These mandates would cut into that revenue, leaving lenders little choice but to raise interest rates, charge new or higher credit card fees, or tighten lending standards altogether. The result would be less credit for folks who need capital to turn their ideas into a business, or businesses who need an affordable credit card to cover expenses. We saw this play out when Congress passed the 2010 Durbin Amendment, which capped debit card processing fees. Although that law also exempted smaller banks, the exemption didn’t work. A Federal Reserve study found that the cap harmed all financial institutions.

I’m also concerned that this bill would harm military families. In Fayetteville, an estimated 12 percent of businesses are veteran-owned, and they should have access to the tools necessary to keep building successful businesses. The Defense Credit Union Council has warned that the Durbin-Marshall credit card mandates would hurt the military community while delivering no meaningful benefits to Main Street. Washington lawmakers shouldn’t make it harder for veterans, or anyone, to secure credit and build a business.

On top of those concerns, the promised savings aren’t guaranteed to reach anyone here. Instead, a University of Miami study projects that big-box retailers–namely Walmart, Costco, Kroger, Amazon, and Home Depot–are expected to pocket a billion-dollar boon from these mandates. Meanwhile, the small businesses that form the backbone of our local economy are estimated to see little to no savings.

Over my decade on the city council and my years running a small business, I learned that Fayetteville grows when people who are willing to work hard have access to the capital they need. Our local lenders make that possible, and the new businesses opening across our city are proof. The Durbin-Marshall credit card mandates would put that progress at risk while sending the savings to the nation’s largest retailers. I urge Senator Tillis and Senator Budd to oppose these mandates and stand with the small businesses that keep our community moving forward.

Bobby Hurst

1713 Yonkers Court

Fayetteville NC  28304

Former Fayetteville City Council member, 2007 – 2017

Get NC political news in your inbox

Free weekday newsletter. Unsubscribe anytime.

Newsletter signup

Complete any confirmation steps below.

Have a message for North Carolina?

Reach readers who follow state policy, elections and the issues shaping their communities.

Advertise with Us